Songs my Brothers Taught Me

The overwhelming global adulation received by the Golden Lion winner and Oscar front-runner, Nomadland, made Chloe Zhao a household name among cinephiles. But her debut feature film Songs My Brothers Taught Me, despite being nominated for the Camera d’Or at Cannes 2015, couldn’t manage to imprint Zhao’s name on cinemascape’s memory. Though not in the same league as Nomadland, her debut holds its own merit and reflects the director’s distinctive sensibility.

A Native American drama, set in the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota, the film explores the bond between Johnny Winters (John Reddy) and his younger sister Jashaun (Jashaun St. John). Johnny is just about to graduate from high school and plans to leave the reservation to go to Los Angeles with his girlfriend, Aurelia (Taysha Fuller). Life has always been tough for the Winters family. We learn that Johnny’s deceased father, a revered rodeo cowboy, had 25 children from nine so-called wives. Needless to say, he was never around for most of his children in their growing up years. Johnny and Jashaun live with their mother Lisa (Irene Bedard) who is an alcoholic and seeks redemption by being devoted to God. Their elder brother, Cody, who is in prison despises her for abandoning them in the past.

Loneliness, existential dread, and poverty are inescapable on the reservation, leading to depression and suicides. The community is trying to come out of alcoholism and addiction. Johnny illegally distributes alcohol to fellow residents to support his family but eventually has to face the wrath of rival bootleggers. The person most affected upon knowing about Johnny’s plan to leave the reservation is Jashaun. For her, Johnny embodies the role of an elder brother, friend, and protector. Lisa, their mother, fears that Jashaun would have to endure the same fate as hers of growing up without an elder for emotional support.

There are some beautiful tender moments in Songs My Brothers Taught me that exhibit Zhao’s compassionate outlook on life for which she has garnered much-deserved acclaim. The moments of sibling bonding set against the vast landscape of the reservation evoke a sense of nostalgia – aided by a touching melancholic score. Zhao explores the romantic connection between Johnny and his girlfriend with some brilliant Terrence Malick like shots of the golden hour and the beauty of nature.

A promising and emotional debut, the film highlights the value of roots and emotional bonds that connect us. Zhao makes us question the idea of leaving one’s ties for a supposedly better life somewhere else. Is it worth breaking free from the past?

Songs my Brothers Taught Me is out on Friday, April 9th on Mubi.

Nomadland

Fern (Frances McDonald) is a beautiful and intelligent middle-aged woman. She is very unusually charming, with her quiet and stern smile. She is also in perfect good health. Someone who could be working in Wall Street. Instead she lives in poverty in the back of her van (not a camper van, but a regular size one), travelling across her large nation in search of temporary employment in fast-food restaurants, factories and so on. She literally has to “handle her own shit”, in reference to the bucket that she uses as a toilet. The film is based on Nomadland: Surviving America in the Twenty-First Century, a non-fiction work penned three years ago by Jessica Bruder.

The nomadic lifestyle is partially Fern’s own choice. She was forced to leave her beautiful house facing the desert in Empire, Nevada, after the local mining company USG shut down, turning the the community into a literal ghost town. Even the post code was discontinued. Plus her husband Bo passed away. Fern could live with her well-off sister Dolly in a large house. But instead she opted to remain entirely independent and to live a life without roots (unlike the plant after which she’s named).

The nomadic mentors Linda May, Charlene Swankie and Bob Wells (all three played by themselves) become some sort of parental figure to Fern. They provide her with very practical advise about survival (such as car maintenance tips), as well as spiritual guidance and comfort. All three have grappled with death in different ways, and found healing in the unconventional lifestyle. Bob created the nomadic community as an opportunity for older Americans let down by the system, and also as a way of coping with his son’s suicide five years earlier. The avuncular septuagenarian Linda is seeking a new purpose after contemplating suicide. She dreams of moving to Arizona, and invites Fern to join her. Swanky’s cancer has metastasised into her brain and she’s only been given eight months to live. She wishes to spend her final days on the road, and not on a hospital bed.

Fern also befriends David (played by the actor David Strathairn), a grey-haired heartthrob with a kind smile permanently attached to his face. They develop a very tender relationship. David is smitten with the charming lady, but it’s never clear whether she reciprocates his feelings. He eventually settles under a roof with his son, daughter-in-law and grandchild. Fern visits them. David asks her to move in. She turns down the invitation, just like she did with her sister.

McDormand is absolutely astounding, her eyes brimming with both pain and the desire to move on. You’d be forgiven for assuming that she was one of the real nomads, just live Linda, Bob and Swankie.

This is palpably real cinema. You can touch and feel the characters. It is also an indictment of the US, and how the richest country in the world has failed very capable people. These nomads are not dysfunctional people. They are perfectly functional Americans who embarked on a very romantic and yet harsh journey due to the lack of financial opportunities. Dolly compares them to the American pioneers. The comparison holds in more ways than one: they are independent, courageous trailblazers braving a nation of continental dimensions in search of pastures green.

Nomadland premiered at the 77th Venice International Film Festival, when this piece was originally written. It was the last film in Competition to be presented, and it received a very warm ovation. It’s not unusual for festivals to save the best for last. It won the Golden Lion for Best Film. It premiered in the UK in October as part of the BFI London Film Festival. In cinemas on Monday, May 17th (as cinemas finally reopen)!