DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema

An American Prayer

Director - Nusrat Durrani - 2021

"Dirty gem"
The American dreams morphs into a nightmare, hallucination or mere "bullshit", as marginalised citizens recall their experience - heartfelt doc premiered at the Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival

When Indian-born Nusrat Durrani arrived in the US as a teenager his head was bursting with excitement. He wanted to make it to the music industry. The American dream mandates that anyone can achieve anything they wish, yet his ambitions seemed hardly tangible, at least at first. Later in the film, we learn that Durrani became a distinguished media mogul, serving as Chairman of MTV Networks’ Diversity Council, and now authoring this deeply personal documentary. The country where he chose to live did not let him down. But Durrani is only one of the many characters in this kaleidoscopic look at American identity. And others did not enjoy the same success as the helmer.

We quickly learn that the US has failed pretty much every single minority. The indigenous people that originally populated what is now the largest country in the Americas have been mostly exterminated. Black people have been marginalised and disenfranchised: there are more black men incarcerated now than there were black males enslaved in 1850. The police have become the new slave masters. Blacks are consistently profiled, with a hapless young man being fatally shot for committing a very unusual offence: jogging.

Durrani notes that the establishment is very ungrateful towards African-Americans: “every American artistic expression started in the black community: folk, Rock, blues, soul, RnB, rap, hiphop, break dancing, tap dancing, spoken word”. Which beggars the question: why does the country punish these people instead of celebrating them?

The Hispanic too have been marginalised. Politicians pay little attention to the fast-growing community, except perhaps at the time of elections. Jacqui delivers a very awkward speech in Spanish in order to lure the Latino vote. Even whites, who make up 62% of the US populations have been historically discriminated: the Slavs, the Italians and the Irish were once perceived as outsiders, and some still struggle to integrate. Disability is also a literal barrier to those reaching for the star-spangled banner. Intersectionality poses a double challenge, reveals a wheelchair-bound African American.

In addition to race and disability, religion also poses a challenge to ordinary Americans, with Muslims suffering from rabid islamophobia for two decades, since 9/11, aided by Donald Trump’s inflammatory rhetoric and proposed blanket ban on travel from all Muslim countries.

These various people describe the elusive American dream as a “nightmare”, a “hallucination” or plain “bullshit”. They can hardly integrate, let alone buy a very large house with abundant consumables. A number of questions are repeatedly raised as these people share their tragic predicament: “Is America possible”, “Did slavery end?”. These uncertainties constantly ripple through the air, intoxicating a country that boasts being “the land of the free”.

The director blends very confessional talking heads statements with archive footage (9/11 is particularly prominent) and poetic devices in order to create a multilayered yet simple and straightforward movie, one both Americans and non-Americans are able to fully comprehend. The voice-overs (from the filmmaker and his characters) are heartfelt, lyrical, at times laborious, as if choking with pain and anguish. The movie often has a vintage feel, with blurry images, wear and tear created digitally in order to resemble dusty 35mm. It’s as if the director was saying: “racism is as deeply imprinted in American society as splodges and scratches on an old film reel”.

Durrani confesses that he was unprepared for the deeply-ingrained racism that permeates every class and every layer of the world’s most powerful nation. As an immigrant, his allegiance remains split between his birth and his home nation. He often wonders how much India has changed in the past 25 years. Durrani could neither say goodbye in person to his mother nor attend her funeral, after she passed away to Covid. At times, the immigrant experience can be cruel and unforgiving.

The film wraps in a more upbeat note, highlighting the personal achievements of the filmmaker, while the oneiric innocence of children sends a refreshing message of hope. Durrani boldly claims: “The American dream isn’t just ours, it belongs to every dreamer in the world”. I wish I could share Durrani’s optimism, but I come from Latin American country (Brazil) consistently subjected to the atrocities of American interventionism: coup d’etats, dictatorships andruthless Friedman-ean experiment.. The American dream has never extended to foreign policy, and it probably never will. Latin America needs to wake up from the American nightmare before we are allowed to dream again.

An American Prayer premiered at the Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival.

"Dirty gem"

By Victor Fraga - 20-12-2021

By Victor Fraga - 20-12-2021

Victor Fraga is a Brazilian born and London-based journalist and filmmaker with more than 20 years of involvement in the cinema industry and beyond. He is an LGBT writer, and describes himself as a di...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
Another year has gone by, and DMovies is [Read More...]
A small family of four lives in a [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]

Read More


Alice Rohrwacher

Victor Fraga - 29-05-2023

Italian director becomes increasingly recognised for her idiosyncratic style, now moving further away from poetic territory into quirky zone - live from Official Competition of the the 76th Cannes Film Festival [Read More...]

The Other Fellow

Matthew Bauer

Eoghan Lyng - 28-05-2023

Imagine sharing your name with a fictional character? Meet the real-life James Bonds, in this very peculiar documentary - now on all major VoD platforms [Read More...]

Homecoming (Le Retour)

Catherine Corsini

Victor Fraga - 28-05-2023

Gingerly multilayered drama about loss and reconnection in Corsica boasts spectacular teenage performances - Catherine Corsini's wildly underrated drama premiered at the 76th Cannes Film Festival - lives from Cannes [Read More...]

Facebook Comment

Website Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *