DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema

Her Socialist Smile

Director - John Gianvito - 2020

"Greasy movie"
Documentarist investigates the ideology of notorious deafblind activist, which the American establishment tried to sweep under the carpet for years - watch it now for free

Helen Keller is an American author, disability rights advocate, political activist and lecturer. She lost her sight and hearing aged just one. Her autobiography The Story of My Life and its dramatic film adaptation The Miracle Worker (Arthur Penn, 1962) made Keller a household name. Academic books across school curricula in the US and elsewhere have focused on her extraordinary life as a deafblind person and her untiring devotion to the cause of disabled people. But American history has conveniently popularised only this aspect of Keller’s life which is universally applauded. Her most controversial facet has been left out of American textbooks as it runs contrary to the country’s political ideology.

The American establishment tried to sweep the ideology of the deafblind activist under the carpet for years. Helen Keller was a staunch socialist who championed the rights of the working class, poor, women’s suffrage, peace, and vociferously revolted against America’s capitalistic culture. Gianvito’s film lays out her public talks and writings on socialism in white text on a black background without any voice-over. As a viewer, we are expected to silently read Keller’s views on the socialist causes she cared for, and understand her mind.

These writings are interspersed with poet Carolyn Forche’s narration of Keller’s increasing role in the socialist movement across the world and her involvement in various labour union strikes. In her various talks, Keller advocated for women voting rights. She went further. She insisted in her public speeches that simply being granted voting rights would not ensure equality for women. Unless women are treated fairly at the workplace and in society, materialistic progress holds no meaning.

She was very critical of her alma mater, the Radcliffe College of Harvard University, where she became the country’s first deafblind person to earn a Bachelor’s degree. Keller felt that Harvard was an imposing monument to dead ideas. She ridiculed the education system for teaching ancient history that holds no significance in our current state of affairs rather than focusing on solving problems of modern-day living.

In Her Socialist Smile, Gianvito attempts to balance the overdose of information with interesting creative and artistic experiments. After Keller’s first-ever public talk that took place in the Hillside Elementary School Auditorium where she urged people to embrace socialism, we hear thunderous applause after the texts have blacked out from the screen. The heavy downpour of rain on a tree sounds like an applause. In the film, Gianvito frequently intercuts close-up shots of trees, snow, water flowing over the rocks, and colourful fishes swimming in the river bodies. These images of nature are from the property of Helen Keller and her teacher Anne Sullivan in Massachusetts.

The film’s screenplay also has frequent intercuts of a charming theatre where Keller once gave a hilarious interview. The interesting Q&A sessions between Keller and the interviewer are juxtaposed as text on the screen with an enchanting piano music piece in the background. We get to learn about the indomitable and lively spirit of Helen Keller who lit a candle to darkness and herself became a light of inspiration for millions. Her humour and optimism for life are best reflected in a very peculiar exchange exchange. Interviewer: “Would you like to get married?”. Helen Keller: “Yes. Are you proposing to me?”

You can watch Her Socialist Smile for free now on the National Gallery of Art’s website – just click here (no sign-in required).

"Greasy movie"

By Arun A. K. - 13-01-2021

By Arun A. K. - 13-01-2021

Good food and a good movie are enough to make Arun’s day. He writes short stories once in a blue moon but enjoys writing about movies that excite him on a regular basis. There is no particular g...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
A small family of four lives in a [Read More...]
Another year has gone by, and DMovies is [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]

Read More

Freaks is a radical diversity statement


Victor Fraga - 28-02-2017

Nearly a century on, Tod Browning's Freaks remains the most radical and misunderstood statement for diversity in film ever made [Read More...]

Girl with no Mouth (Peri)

Can Evrenol

Victor Fraga - 24-11-2019

Four deformed children fight for their survival in a dystopian post-apocalyptic society, in unusual kids' horror/fantasy movie from Turkey - live from the Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival [Read More...]

Locked In: Breaking the Silence

Xavier Alford

- 29-11-2020

A documentarist suffering from a very rare condition confronts his fears by talking to other patients and their families - on BFI Player and BBC4 on Monday, November 30th [Read More...]

Facebook Comment

Website Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *