DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema
Director - Christian Petzold - 2018

"Dirty gem"
Just a little bit of history repeating? Audacious German film transposes Holoucast novel from 1942 onto modern Marseilles; the outcome is odd and yet bewitching - from the Berlinale


This is an extremely peculiar film and not an easy one to watch. It’s not light entertainment. It is so incredibly multi-faceted and original that it might cause estrangement at first. Yet, it’s a film you won’t easily forget. You will catch yourself mulling over its unusual story, trying to weave together its various narrative strands and political connotations.

Georg (Franz Rogowski) escapes to Marseilles after the German troops approach Paris. He’s carrying the papers of a communist writer called Weidel, who committed suicide out of fear of persecution. These papers include a manuscript of a book, two letters to his wife and a document from the Mexican Embassy granting him a visa to enter the country. Georg assumes Weidel’s identity in an attempt to flee war-ridden Europe. This purposely asymmetrical film relocates a Holocaust-drama into modern France, complete with refugees from North Africa and beyond. Viewers are left to dovetail the two different times and realities.

This is a wilfully hybrid endeavour in more than one way. The plot from the past fuses with the themes from the present, and so do the props. Georg wears clothes from the 1940s, the documents are printed with old-fashioned calligraphy. Otherwise, the settings are modern: digital devices and 21st century cars are to be seen everywhere. Georg’s predicament is further complicated with the arrival of the beautiful and enigmatic Marie (played by Paula Beer, who was catapulted to fame two years ago in François Ozon’s equally cryptic Frantz). Her identity is as elusive as her motives, nevertheless the two become predictably infatuated with each other (and that’s about the only predictable element of the movie).

Georg, who has a soft-spoken and child-like voice, develops a gentle bond with Driss (Lilien Batman), the mixed-race child of his buddy Heinz (who died whilst fleeing). Driss’s mother is a deaf immigrant from North Africa, and they live in the Maghreb outskirts of Marseilles. This is an allusion to the refugee crisis befalling Europe right now. While the political tones of the film are not entirely overt, it’s not difficult to join the dots in this case. Georg and Driss are obliquely the byproduct of war and political persecution. They represent Europe’s failure to shelter and protect the most vulnerable people, both during WW2 and now.

Ultimately, the message of Transit is: “look, history is repeating itself, we’re making the same errors as in the past. The calligraphy and the clothes may have changed in the past three quarters of a century, yet we have hardly learnt our lesson.”

Transit is showing at the 68th Berlin International Film Festival. It is a free adaptation of the 1942 book Transit Visa by German writer Anna Sheghers. The German director is a regular at the event, yet he has never won the Festival’s top prize, the Golden Bear. Could 2018 become his big year? This possibility is indeed on the table.

"Dirty gem"

By Victor Fraga - 17-02-2018

By Victor Fraga - 17-02-2018

Victor Fraga is a Brazilian born and London-based writer with more than 15 years of involvement ...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
What happens when an independent female filmmaker with [Read More...]
Fifty years have passed since students joined forces [Read More...]

Read More

10 films that depict the post-Holocaust experience


Jack Hawkins - 25-06-2019

Jack Hawkins lists 10 dirty movies that are preoccupied with the aftermath of the systematic extermination of Jews during WW2 in Europe [Read More...]

In Fabric

Peter Strickland

Jeremy Clarke - 24-06-2019

A red dress bought from and returned to a department store wreaks a terrible fate on its serial owners in a film much stranger and more worthwhile than it sounds - in cinemas from Friday, June 28th [Read More...]


Władysław Pasikowski

Eoghan Lyng - 22-06-2019

Philippe Tłokiński stars as real-life Polish war hero Jan Nowak-Jeziorański in the latest blockbuster from cult director Władysław Pasikowski - in cinemas Friday, June 28th [Read More...]

Facebook Comment

Website Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *