DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema
Director - Joshua Weinstein - 2017

"Mostly clean movie"
Tale about a clumsy father and widower in the hermetically closed Hasidic community of New York has a universal topic, but lacks a certain dramatic fizz - in cinemas Friday

This a a golden opportunity to deep dive into the heart of the highly secretive and insular Hasidic Jewish community of Brooklyn, in New York City. Menashe (Menashe Lustig) is a kind and yet clumsy and socially inept grocery store clerk. His wife has now passed away and he wants to keep custody of his only child Rieven (Ruben Niborski), but he faces an uphill struggle from his very own ultra-conservative group, which does not approve of a single man raising a boy.

The topic of the young and blundering widower rediscovering life and in some ways behaving like a bachelor, unable to keep his house clean and cook for himself, is quite universal. At moments, I could almost picture a Hollywood comedy such as Mrs Doubtfire (Chris Columbus, 1993). There is an enormous pressure for Menashe to remarry, and his attempts at finding a last-minute wife are funny and awkward. All decisions are ultimately made by the Ruv (a senior master), so Menashe has to come across as a presentable and viable father and citizen to everyone he comes across, lest they rat on him.

Ultimately, this is not a film about the religion, and the issues are relatable for people of most creeds and in mostcorners of the world. But the script isn’t entirely riveting. It lacks subplots, and the consistent focus of Menashe’s plight just isn’t effective enough from both a cinematic and a dramatic perspective The stoical attitude of the community sometimes borders the monotonous. Despite the universality of the topic, the movie often banal. It’s more interesting to watch as a peek into an hermetically closed society than a compelling drama.

Menashe is out in cinemas in the UK on Friday, November 3rd. The film has previously toured the US and Europe, and showed at various film festivals.



"Mostly clean movie"

By Victor Fraga - 06-12-2017

By Victor Fraga - 06-12-2017

Victor Fraga is a Brazilian born and London-based writer with more than 15 years of involvement i...

DMovies Poll

Should smoking in cinema be banned?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
Perhaps no other 20th century artist has captured [Read More...]
Time flies by! DMovies was launched in February [Read More...]
The British and the French have joined efforts! [Read More...]
Turn on the fan on and grab yourself [Read More...]
Films quotes are very powerful not just because [Read More...]

Read More

Vita Activa: The Spirit of Hannah Arendt

Ada Ushpitz
2016

Victor Fraga - 13-04-2016

The Jew who humanised the Nazis: compelling documentary rescues the legacy of Jewish-German philosopher Hannah Arendt while shedding a new light on ever-so-urgent problems such as the refugee crisis. [Read More...]

Ben-Gurion: Epilogue

Yariv Mozer
2016

Victor Fraga - 09-08-2016

Is this the friendly face of Israel? New doc reveals unforeseen interview with the founder of Israel after he retired from politics; we see an avuncular and apparently balanced old man, but his rhetoric is sometimes ambiguous - from the Jewish Film Festival [Read More...]

Dimona Twist

Michal Aviad
2016

Lina Samoili - 12-08-2016

The women of the desert: how did these modern young women start a new life and a build a society in the middle of the desert in the early years of Israel? Michal Avid's doc is a tribute to female strength and resilience [Read More...]

Facebook Comment

Website Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *